Skip to main content
Unlimited live 1‑on‑1 sessions. Try 14 days free, then $299/mo.

Speediance vs Tonal: which to buy, and the 3-year cost

Tonal vs Speediance at list prices: the 3-year cost, wall or floor, what still works without a subscription, and adding a live coach to either one.

A woman pulls a cable handle across her body in her living room while her coach watches on a phone mounted on a small tripod on the floor
In this article10

The short answer

Buy the Speediance for the lower price, no required monthly fee and a frame that folds away. Buy the Tonal if you can bolt it to a wall and want more classes and a built-in camera. Neither has a person watching you lift. A coach on video can, on either one.

We don't sell either machine, we aren't affiliated with Tonal or Speediance, and there are no affiliate links on this page. We're a live video coaching service, and our coaches train members on both machines every week. Our founder has owned a Speediance Gym Monster 2 for two years. The Tonal side comes from Tonal's own pages. Every price below is a list price, checked in November 2026.

Which one to buy

  • Pick Tonal if you own your home, have a wall with studs and a ceiling of about 7 ft 10 in (2.4 m), and want the bigger library: 3,000+ workouts by Tonal's count, against 1,000+ on Speediance's Gym Monster 2 page.12 It sets your weight for you, and its camera gives form cues on some moves. You'll pay $59.95 a month for at least a year, and for as long as you want those features.
  • Pick Speediance if you rent, might move, want to spend about $3,200 less over three years, or would rather not pay monthly at all. Free Lift, custom workouts and the weight modes need no subscription. The Gym Monster 2 is the cheapest way in, and the Gym Monster 3 adds a bigger screen and voice control for $250 more. The Gym Monster 3S is the one to get if you want a little more weight than a Tonal's 250 lb (113 kg): it goes to 260 lb (118 kg).
  • Plan a person in if you've bought equipment before and stopped using it. Both machines are great places to lift, and neither has someone waiting for you on Tuesday. What a coach adds on either is further down.

Side by side

Tonal: a panel on the wall, arms folded at rest
A Tonal on a pale wall with its arms folded down and the handles hanging at the bottom, screen dark, a rolled mat, a water bottle and a towel on the floor below
Speediance Gym Monster 2: a frame that stands on the floor
A Speediance Gym Monster 2 unfolded against a wall, its screen dark and the handles clipped at waist height, a rolled mat on the platform, a water bottle and a towel beside it

The current models, at list prices:

Tonal 2Speediance Gym Monster 2
List price$4,2953$3,849 to $4,599 by package4
Delivery and setup$295 installation, required and not refundable ($495 if you're more than 100 miles (160 km) from a hub)56Free to your door, not inside. Inside delivery is about $100 to $300, to the room you choose about $200 to $4007
Monthly fee$59.95, required for the first 12 months1None required. Wellness Plus, the optional AI tier, is $19.99 a month or $169.99 a year8
Most weight250 lb (113 kg), 125 lb (57 kg) per arm, in 1 lb (0.5 kg) steps9220 lb (100 kg) in 1 lb (0.5 kg) steps. The Gym Monster 3S goes to 260 lb (118 kg)1011
How it fitsBolted to wall studs, 21.5 in (55 cm) wide, with 7 by 7 ft (2.1 by 2.1 m) of clear floor in front5Stands on the floor, 48 by 27 in (122 by 69 cm) open, folds to 15 in (38 cm) deep10
Bench and barSold separately. The $495 Essential bundle has a bench, bar, handles and rope12A bar comes with every package. Works ($4,049) and up add a bench, according to reviews4
CameraBuilt in, with automated form cues on some moves13None on the machine10
Warranty2 years, parts and labor142 years, cables 1 year; you pay for on-site repair labor15
Returns30 days from installation; the $295 isn't refunded630 days from delivery; return shipping and handling come out of the refund16

What the table can't show is the software. Tonal's app has 4.9 stars from about 11,000 US ratings on iPhone and 5.0 from about 1,600 on Android. Speediance's has 4.4 from 13 ratings and 3.4 from 178.17 With Tonal, that polish is what the monthly fee pays for.

The newer Gym Monster 3 ($4,099) adds a bigger screen and voice control at the same 220 lb (100 kg). The 3S Core ($4,599) is the one that goes to 260 lb (118 kg).411

What still works if you stop paying

This decides what you actually own, so it's worth asking before you buy.

Tonal without the membership

  • Only once your first 12 months are paid
  • Basic Lift: pick a handle, bar or rope move and set the weight with a dial
  • Generic moves only, one set at a time
  • No demos, weight suggestions, weight modes or spotter
  • No classes, programs or custom workouts

Speediance without a subscription

  • From day one, free for life by Speediance's word
  • Free Lift, the class library and custom workouts
  • All four weight modes and the safety features
  • Weight suggestions, partner mode and your history
  • You lose AI plans, AI workouts and phone-camera tracking

Tonal describes Basic Lift as "like walking up to the dumbbell rack or cable machine at the gym: you set the pace, track your weights, keep yourself motivated, and monitor your own form".18 Speediance says its free features "remain unchanged and free for life".19 Weight modes, if you haven't met them, are settings such as chains or eccentric that change how heavy each part of a rep feels. On a Tonal the spotter is one of them, which is why it goes with the membership.20

So a Tonal is a subscription product with a very good machine attached, and a Speediance is a machine with an optional subscription. Neither is wrong. They're different deals.

Three years of each

Before tax, at list prices, both with a bench:

Total cost over three years, with a bench
  • Tonal 2 with bundle, install and membership: $7,243
  • Tonal 2, membership year one only, then Basic Lift: $5,804
  • Gym Monster 2 Works with Wellness Plus yearly: $4,559
  • Gym Monster 2 Works, no subscription: $4,049

Tonal's promotion terms (for its regular price), membership and FAQ pages; Speediance's store and Wellness pages; Garage Gym Reviews for Tonal's bundle; all November 12, 2026. Wellness Plus at $169.99 a year. Our arithmetic

The top bar is $4,295 for the machine, $495 for the bundle, $295 to install and 36 months of membership. Tonal's figures include getting the machine on the wall; the Speediance ones don't include carrying it inside, which adds about $100 to $400 if you need it.

Not sure you'll stick with it? Tonal Rent is $279 a month with the bundle, installation and membership included and no minimum term.21 Our Tonal price guide works out when renting stops making sense, and what a used machine sells for is the other half of any three-year sum.

Wall or floor

Each machine and the space to train in, seen from above, to the same scale

Tonal FAQ, Speediance Gym Monster 2 page and Innerbody, read November 12, 2026. The Gym Monster's training area is drawn as a square of equal area, about 40 sq ft

Neither saves you much room while you train. Tonal asks for 49 sq ft (4.6 m²) of clear floor, and Innerbody's testers put the Gym Monster 2 at about 40 sq ft (3.7 m²).522 The difference is what happens afterwards.

The Tonal takes almost no floor when you're not using it. It sticks out about 5 in (13 cm) from the wall and weighs nearly 150 lb (68 kg), so Tonal's installers fix it to the studs like a TV mount. Tonal says a 7 ft (2.1 m) ceiling can still work, and that 7 ft 10 in lets the arms extend fully.5 If you rent, that means a conversation with your landlord. If you move, it means one of Tonal's paid relocation kits and arranging the transport yourself.23

The Gym Monster needs no drilling and arrives assembled. It weighs about 172 lb (78 kg), rolls on two rear wheels across a flat floor and folds up against a wall.10 Free shipping stops at your door, though. Inside delivery gets it indoors, usually on the ground floor. For a room upstairs, White Glove takes it to the room you choose.7

Form feedback and the weights

Both machines measure every rep through the cables. Only one has a camera.

Tonal 2 has a camera built into the screen. Tonal's cable-based cues run on every move, and its camera-based cues cover "a subset of moves", by its own help centre. The cues look at things like knees caving in, pace, balance and range of motion. Tonal also sets your weight before each set and raises it as you get stronger, and its spotter, on by default, lightens the load if you stall.1320

Speediance has no camera on the machine. Its cable sensors give feedback on "force control, stable amplitude, and bilateral balance", and between sets it suggests the weight for your next one.10 Its paid Wellness Plus tier adds phone-camera tracking for about 70 moves, on an iPhone 16 or a recent Android flagship. The "real-time form correction" its sales page lists is, by its own August release notes, still coming.824

If camera form cues matter to you, Tonal is ahead by a distance. But both are automated. A machine can tell you your left side is pulling harder. It isn't built to tell you why, or to catch your lower back starting to round on rep 8 of a Romanian deadlift (a hip hinge, where you push your hips back with the bar or handles in front of your thighs).

Is Speediance as good as Tonal?

Close, with two differences that show up when you lift. Innerbody's testers, comparing the Tonal 2 and Gym Monster 2, found both "incredibly smooth". At heavier loads they noticed "some trembling in the frame" of the Speediance, which "never occurred with Tonal", and Tonal's weight modes felt harder on the lowering part of each rep.22 So the same number on the two screens may not feel the same, and the most-weight row in the table isn't the whole story.

Height is the other one. Their tester over six feet (1.83 m) found lat pulldowns and triceps extensions awkward on the Speediance, because its compact frame limits the range of motion at the highest pulley setting, and had no such trouble on the Tonal.22

What a coach adds on either machine

Neither maker sells 1‑on‑1 coaching. Tonal's live classes go one way, and its help centre puts it plainly: "Only you can see the coach. The coach or any other members cannot see you."25 Speediance's classes are recorded, and its "AI coach" is the Wellness Plus tier.

A coach on video is the person who sees rep 8 of that Romanian deadlift. They demonstrate the hinge on camera and give you a weight for the first set. When your lower back starts to round, they stop the set there and take some weight off the next one. Next week's program starts from what they saw. If you wear an Apple Watch or a Bluetooth heart rate strap, they see your heart rate live too, and use it to decide when to push and when to rest.

Coach Angela shows a move on our founder's phone, propped on a stand on the floor. His Speediance is in the self-view, top right

The setup is the same on both. A phone or laptop goes on the floor a few feet back, usually side-on, so your coach can see you and the machine (our camera setup guide shows why). The call runs on that device, since neither maker lists video calls on the machine's own screen. Your coach writes the program in the Bespoke Fit app and demonstrates each movement (a row is a row on any equipment), and you do it in the machine's free lifting mode.

  • On a Speediance, you lift in Free Lift, which you keep with or without Wellness Plus. More in coaching on a Speediance.
  • On a Tonal, with the membership you run the session in Free Lift, with Tonal's demos and modes. Without it, after the first year, Basic Lift still works: you set each weight from your program on the dial, one set at a time, so there's a little more tapping between sets. Either way your coach watches the movement and you run the screen, so they don't need to know Tonal's menus. More in coaching on a Tonal.
A man resting on a bench between sets, a towel round his neck, smiling as he talks to his coach on a laptop set on a low stool

Every one of our coaches has coached on a Speediance, so the machine isn't new to them. Our founder trains this way on his Gym Monster 2, and it's the only kit he uses. He paid for Speediance's membership for a while, then stopped, because for him it didn't add much and training on his own was boring. His two-year review has the rest.

Home machines rarely go quiet because they break. Commonplace, which resells used Tonals, says most are "collateral damage from life changes", like a move or a lapsed membership.26 With a coach, the routine isn't yours alone to hold. They book each session with you, it lands in your calendar with reminders, and you turn up to a plan that's already written. Henrik, 36, one of our members, put it like this about his coach:

I'd get demotivated and just stop showing up. Knowing Tris is waiting for me at every session means I actually go.

The machine is the part you've already decided to pay for. The coach is the part that gets you on it on the days you'd rather not.

Each coach has 12 members at most, a cap we enforce, so yours remembers last week and plans the next one from it. Sessions run 45 to 90 minutes, and most people settle at around an hour. They're unlimited for $299 a month: about $23 per coached hour at three a week and about $17 at four, because the fourth costs nothing extra.

You start with a 30-minute strategy call with a head coach, who matches you to a coach, so say which machine you have. The first 14 days are free, counted from your first session, which is enough to find out whether a person on the call is what your machine was missing.

It isn't for everyone. If the machine already keeps you training and its programs suit you, keep doing that. If $299 a month on top of a machine is too much, skip us. And if you haven't bought a machine yet, a coach can work with a few hundred dollars of kit too.

Before you order

Check these first

  • Measure the ceiling and find the studs before ordering a Tonal
  • For a Speediance, measure every doorway and stair between the curb and the room
  • Decide who carries a 172 lb (78 kg) machine inside, or book inside or White Glove delivery
  • If you rent, ask your landlord before anything goes on a wall
  • Both makers run sales from time to time, so check their stores before you pay list price
  • Read the return terms: the Tonal install fee isn't refunded, and Speediance deducts return costs
  • If you want a coach on video, plan where the phone or laptop will sit

Common questions

Can I train with a personal trainer on a Tonal or Speediance? Yes, over live video. Neither maker sells 1‑on‑1 coaching, so the call runs on a phone, tablet or laptop set on the floor. You lift in the machine's free lifting mode while the coach watches each set and adjusts.

Can two people share one machine? Yes, both are built for it. One Tonal membership covers unlimited accounts on the machine. Speediance's free features include a partner mode, but Wellness Plus is sold per account, and a family plan for two costs $269.99 a year. With us, each of you has your own membership and your own coach-written program, and partners who both train with us get a couples discount, so ask us about it.

What is a cheaper alternative to Speediance? Within Speediance, the Gym Monster 2 Basic package lists at $3,849, with a bar but no bench. Outside smart machines, a few hundred dollars of dumbbells and a bench still wins on strength per dollar, without the motor, the screen or the weight modes.

Bespoke Fit is not affiliated with Tonal or Speediance. Prices and features are the makers' own, checked on the dates in the sources.

Sources

  1. Tonal, 2026. Membership: "$59.95/month plus applicable tax. 12-month initial commitment required", month to month after that, "One membership for the whole household", "Thousands of live and on-demand classes across 16 workout types", "3,000+ expert-designed workouts", and what non-members keep ("Basic Lift with the ability to increase/decrease the weight"). tonal.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2

  2. Speediance, 2026. Gym Monster 2: "1000+ Coach-Curated Workouts" and "90+ Smart Scheduled Fitness Plans". Its other counts differ by page: its app guide, November 2, 2026, says the free core has "400+ courses, 70+ plans and 1,000+ exercises", and its Gym Monster 3 page says "90+ programs, 500+ courses and 1000+ movements". Read November 12, 2026. ↩

  3. Tonal, 2026. 2026 holiday promotion terms: a new Tonal 2 Trainer at its "regular price of $4,295", and "Taxes, Tonal Membership fees, delivery and installation fees, and any additional items purchased separately are additional." tonal.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  4. Speediance, 2026. Store, list prices: Gym Monster 2 Basic $3,849, Works $4,049, Works Plus $4,199, Family Plus $4,599; Gym Monster 3 Core $4,099; Gym Monster 3S Core $4,599; "30-Day Return" and "Free Shipping". speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. The US pages don't list package contents. That every package includes a barbell, Basic has no bench and Works adds a flat bench comes from published reviews (T3, Yahoo) and Speediance's European package comparison. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  5. Tonal, 2026. FAQ: installation at $295, $495 more than 100 miles from a hub and $550 in Alaska and Hawaii; "nearly 150 pounds"; 21.5 in wide and about 5 in deep; 7 by 7 ft of floor, 7 ft of wall and a ceiling of at least 7 ft 10 in; "unlimited accounts for each Tonal"; returns within 30 days of installation. Tonal's installation page adds studs 16 to 24 in apart, that a 7 ft ceiling "can still work", and that 7 ft 10 in lets the arms extend fully. tonal.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  6. Tonal, last updated August 12, 2025. Terms of sale: delivery and installation charges "are nonrefundable", and refunds "may take up to 45 days". tonal.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2

  7. Speediance. Shipping policy: free standard shipping is "Threshold Delivery only", which excludes "indoor, backyard, or upstairs delivery"; Inside Delivery, "approximately USD 100–300 per item", goes to "a first-floor or other accessible indoor area, usually not upstairs"; White Glove, to the room of your choice, is "approximately USD 200–400 per item". speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2

  8. Speediance, 2026. Wellness Plus: Wellness Go $6.99 a month; Wellness Plus $19.99 a month or $169.99 a year; a family plan at $269.99 a year for 2 people; "Each customer needs to register an account and activate the service"; "Yes, you can still use most of Gym Monster's training features, except for training plans and AI features"; and "Real-time form correction and feedback" among the listed features. speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2

  9. Tonal Help Center, updated May 20, 2026. Max supported weight: "250 lbs (Tonal 2) of digital weight", "125 lbs per each arm", in one-pound increments. Read November 12, 2026. ↩

  10. Speediance, 2026. Gym Monster 2: "Maximum weight of 220 lbs/100kg and an adjustable increment of 1 lb/0.5kg", 48.0 by 27.2 by 72.8 in unfolded and 14.6 by 27.2 by 72.8 in folded, about 172 lb, "No Assembly, No Drilling, and No Wall Mounting". No camera appears in the specifications. Its smart fitness page describes feedback on "force control, stable amplitude, and bilateral balance", and Speediance's weight recommendation post, May 21, 2026, says it "suggests the ideal weights for your next set". The FAQ says it moves on two rear wheels over flat floors. speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

  11. Speediance, 2026. Gym Monster 3: "Up to 260 lbs on GM3S, 220 lbs on GM3", a 23.8 in screen and voice control. speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2

  12. Garage Gym Reviews, updated November 4, 2026. Tonal 2 review: the Essential accessory bundle at $495, with Smart Handles, Smart Bar and its control module, rope, weight bench, mat and roller, and "If you just buy the Tonal 2, you get the machine, and that's it." Read November 12, 2026. ↩

  13. Tonal Help Center, updated April 21, 2026. Coaching Cues: cable-based cues "automatically enabled for all movements" in Free Lift, custom and guided strength workouts, looking at "symmetry, balance, range of motion, and pacing". Tonal Smart View, updated January 27, 2026: "currently only a subset of moves contain camera-based Coaching Cues." Read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2

  14. Tonal, updated August 4, 2025. Limited warranty: the trainer, including the touchscreen, 2 years for parts, shipping and labor; smart accessories 1 year; original owner only. tonal.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  15. Speediance, updated August 3, 2026. Warranty: "Complete unit, excluding cable" 24 months, cables 12 months, original purchaser only, on-site repair labor at the owner's expense. speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  16. Speediance. Refund policy: requests "within 30 calendar days" of delivery, and for returns that aren't defects, "all costs related to packaging, labor, storage, transportation, and other logistics" are "deducted in advance from the refund". speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  17. US app stores, read November 12, 2026: Tonal on iPhone, 4.9 out of 5 from 11K ratings; Tonal on Android, 5.0 from 1.61K reviews; Speediance on iPhone, 4.4 from 13 ratings; Speediance on Android, 3.4 from 178 reviews. ↩

  18. Tonal Help Center, updated February 27, 2026. Basic Lift: your experience without a Tonal membership: Basic Lift "can access Generic Moves only" and "can plan and complete single sets only", without "Movement demos", "Weight suggestions" or "Dynamic weight modes", available "when you cancel or pause your membership after completing the 12-month membership commitment". Read November 12, 2026. ↩

  19. Speediance. Wellness launch update: "all existing free features remain unchanged and free for life", listing workouts, custom workouts, Free Lift, the Standard, Chain, Eccentric and Fixed-Speed modes, partner mode, smart weight recommendations, safety features and personal data tracking. speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  20. Tonal Help Center. Suggested weights, updated June 11, 2025: weight recommended and adjusted "before each set". Dynamic weight modes, updated April 16, 2025: five modes in two groups, "Assistance Modes, like Spotter and Burnout" and "Weight Modes, including Smart Flex, Chains, and Eccentric"; Spotter "reduces weight if you struggle" and is "always on by default". Read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2

  21. Tonal, 2026. Tonal Rent: $279 a month for a Tonal 2, including the machine, the Essential bundle, installation and the membership, with "no minimum term", subject to approval in the contiguous 48 states. tonal.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  22. Innerbody Research, Daniel Imperiale, updated July 25, 2025. Tonal vs. Speediance, comparing the Tonal 2 and Gym Monster 2: "Both machines offer incredibly smooth resistance"; "we noticed some trembling in the frame at heavier levels of resistance" on the Speediance, which "never occurred with Tonal"; Tonal's weight modes "more accurate and more challenging during eccentric portions of a lift"; "One of our testers is over six feet tall, and everything from lat pull-downs to tricep extensions posed a problem for him", with "no such sacrifices" on Tonal; and "Tonal requires 49 square feet of space, while Speediance requires just 40 square feet." Read November 12, 2026. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  23. Tonal, 2026. Relocation: paid relocation kits, "transportation of your Tonal and wall mounts is not included". tonal.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  24. Speediance, August 11, 2026. Product updates, July 2026: Sidekick uses "their phone camera for real-time movement recognition", "currently supports around 70 movements", needs an iPhone 16 or newer or a recent Android flagship and an active Wellness+ membership, and "Future updates will bring more intelligent and personalized training support, including movement correction." speediance.com, read November 12, 2026. ↩

  25. Tonal Help Center, updated January 29, 2026. Live workouts: "Only you can see the coach. The coach or any other members cannot see you." Read November 12, 2026. ↩

  26. Commonplace, May 10, 2026. Buying a used Tonal: "Most used Tonals on the market aren't broken. They're collateral damage from life changes", naming moves, lapsed memberships and owners who "upgraded to a competing system or stopped working out at home altogether". Commonplace buys and sells used home gym equipment. Read November 12, 2026. ↩

Live, every rep.

A coach on live video for every session, correcting your form while the bar is still in your hands. 14 days free.

Your coach, liveMatched to you
Try 14 days free

Then $299/mo. Cancel anytime.