Does scheduling workouts help? What makes them stick
The appointment effect, tested: a calendar slot helps less than you'd think. Here's what does get people to show up for workouts, and a week to copy.
Updated

In this article7
The short answer
A little, but less than you'd hope. A workout in your calendar is more likely to happen that day, yet in a trial of 877 gym members, planning two weeks of sessions added no visits. What worked in a six-month trial was making the plan together with another person.
So if you've put "gym, 6 pm" in your calendar and watched it slide to 7, then to tomorrow, then off the screen, nothing is wrong with you. It's what the best gym trial found. A time on its own is a wish with a timestamp.
People sometimes call this the appointment effect: book a workout like a meeting and it happens. That's half right, and the half that's wrong is worth knowing. If you only want the setup, the 15-minute week is further down. If you'd rather someone else held the plan, that's what we do. Run a gym? There's a section for you at the end.
Why the calendar block didn't work
The cleanest test of "just schedule it" comes from a private gym in a big Midwestern city.1 Half the members picked the day and hour of every workout for the next two weeks, and were sent their plans as calendar invitations. The other half only wrote down what they'd done in the past two weeks. The gym's check-in records did the counting.
The planners went 2.3 times in those two weeks. The others went 2.6 times. Planning didn't add a single visit.
Two details explain a lot of failed calendar blocks:
- People booked about three times what they did. The average planner put down 7 visits and made 2.3. A plan that ambitious is mostly a list of sessions you'll feel bad about.
- More plans didn't mean more visits. People were more than twice as likely to go on a day they'd planned, yet they made no more visits in total. The researchers wonder whether each plan carried less weight when there were so many, and whether slowly realising how far behind they were might have been discouraging.
The researchers also point out that a gym is open every day, so a plan to go on Tuesday is less pressing than a plan for a one-day event like a flu clinic. Our reading of that: nothing is lost by sliding a workout one day, so every slot is up for renegotiation, and the tired version of you at 5:45 pm is a very good negotiator. It's an argument willpower tends to lose.
What a bare time slot lacks is a reason not to move it.
What to add to the time slot
Here's what the research says you can add, roughly the most useful first.
1. Make the plan with someone
This is the step most advice skips. Researchers followed 257 local council employees for six months.2 Some made a specific exercise plan on their own (which days, what time, where). Some were just given a partner. Some made that plan together with a partner, and some did none of it.
Planning alone did no better than doing nothing, on most measures. Neither did having a partner. The group that planned together came out more active than every other group at one, three and six months, and lost the most weight too. The activity was self-reported, so take the size of the gap loosely. The pattern is the useful part: a buddy on its own wasn't enough, and neither was a plan on its own. Together, they worked.
Our guess at why: a plan you made with someone is two people's plan. Moving it means a message to them, and the knowledge that they kept their side. That small cost is exactly what the bare time slot was missing.
The person can be a friend, a partner, a neighbour or a coach. They don't have to train with you or live nearby. What counts is that you sat down and agreed the plan together. The week below shows what that ten-minute chat covers. If you're weighing a friend against a professional for this role, accountability partners vs paid coaches goes through the trade-offs.
2. Plan for what gets in the way
You may have met the famous number from Atomic Habits: 91% of people who wrote down when and where they'd exercise did it at least once a week, against 35 to 38% of everyone else. It's a real study, but a small one that ran for two weeks.3
Pooled across many studies since, planning when and where helps people move a little more on average, far less than 91%, and some trials, like the gym one above, found nothing. It works better when people also plan for what might get in the way.4
Make it yours: give each slot one backup line, written before you need it. If this slot falls through, then that one. There's an example in the week below.
3. A reminder, ideally from a person
A huge experiment at a US gym chain tested 54 programs on its members.5 All but a comparison group got the same basic package: a weekly schedule, a text 30 minutes before each planned workout, and points worth about 22 cents a visit. That raised visits by 9% over the comparison group, who got points for signing up and nothing else. It's real, and it's small. A reminder fixes forgetting, and plenty of skipped workouts aren't forgotten. They're postponed.
Who sends the reminder may matter more. At one medical practice, a call from someone on the front desk cut missed appointments clearly more than an automated call did (the numbers are below).6 That's doctors' appointments, not workouts, so take it as a strong hint rather than proof.
Make it yours: set an alarm 30 minutes before each slot, labelled with what you'll do. It's free and it helps a bit. Better still, ask the person you planned with to send a "still on for tomorrow?" text the night before.
4. Something to lose (optional, and not for everyone)
Stakes work for some people, and very few people want them.
At a Fortune 500 company, researchers paid staff $10 a visit to the workplace gym for a month.7 They went about twice as often, then mostly drifted back once the money stopped. Half of them were then offered a deal: put down your own money, and lose it to charity if you go more than two weeks without a visit over the next two months. Only about one in eight took it. Even so, averaged over everyone offered the deal, takers or not, gym visits stayed about 25% higher than in a group never paid at all, for the rest of the year. The other half, paid for the month but never offered the deal, ended up roughly where they started.
In the gym-chain experiment, on the other hand, asking people to type or sign a pledge added nothing to the basic package.5 A gym membership doesn't count as a stake either. That money is already gone whether you go or not, which is why so many people pay for the gym and still don't go.
If a lost bet would make you feel like a failure and quit harder, skip this one. Build around people, not penalties.
When you miss one, plan the comeback
The best program in the whole gym-chain experiment wasn't bigger payments or clever messages. It was a bonus of about 9 cents for coming back after a missed workout.5 That program raised visits by 27% compared with the comparison group, and by 16% compared with the basic package.
Nine cents isn't the point. Making the return easy and a little bit nice seems to be. One missed day barely dents a habit; a gap that keeps growing is what fades it.
So decide what happens after a miss now, while you're calm, rather than at 9 pm on the day you skipped. Make the first session back short and easy, give it a small treat, and if a whole week goes, book the next slot that day instead of waiting for a Monday. There's a full plan for longer gaps in how to restart training after falling off.
Set up your week in 15 minutes
Here's how it all looks for one ordinary week. Say you're hoping to train four times a week and have managed about one.
Book the number you'll keep, not the number you want
If you're hoping for four, book two, and remember the gym-trial planners who booked seven. Add a third slot once two have held for a month.
Write each slot as one full sentence
"Tuesday, 7:15 am, spare room, 30 minutes: squats, counter push-ups and rows with a loaded backpack." "Saturday, 10 am, the park, a 40-minute brisk walk, then ten step-ups on each leg on a bench." Pick times you can protect; whether morning or evening is better matters much less than that.
Make the plan with your person
Ten minutes with your person. Agree both slots, what you'll each do, and what happens if one of you can't make it. Here, your friend does the same Tuesday session at home and you text each other "done" by 8. The Saturday walk is the two of you.
Write the backup and the comeback
Backup: "If Tuesday falls apart, Wednesday at 12:30, 20 minutes, same moves." Comeback: "After a miss, the next session is 15 minutes, and coffee from the good place afterwards." Then set the alarms.
Lay it out the night before
Shoes by the door, the backpack already loaded. At 7:15 am, hunting for kit is where the renegotiating starts.
Check in on Sunday, for five minutes
Count sessions done, not sessions planned. If two held, keep two. If they didn't, change the time or the person before you change anything else.
The first couple of months are where most people drift, so this is worth keeping up past week six, when the novelty has gone and the routine hasn't set yet.
Most of this was measured in weeks, not years
Most of these studies counted whether people turned up over a few weeks, not whether they were still going a year later. That matters, because a habit takes longer to form than most of them ran. Effects fade, too: in the gym-chain experiment, only 8% of programs still made a measurable difference in the weeks after they ended.5
The plan-it-together trial is one of the few that ran for six months, and its effect was still there at the end. So if you change one thing this week, make it that: two sessions, planned with one person, and the comeback decided before you need it.
What changes when your person is a coach
Everything above is free, and a friend who keeps their side is a fine person to plan with. A coach adds three things a friend can't. Your friend's weeks fall apart too, and the shared slot can go with them; being in the slot is your coach's job. Your friend holds the time but can't tell you what to do in it. And your friend gets a "done" text, where your coach watched every set.
That's what we built Bespoke Fit around, so we're not neutral here. Every session is a live 1‑on‑1 video call with your own coach, inside our app on iPhone, Android or a browser. Here's how this article's list looks with us:
| What the research says to add | With a coach on the call |
|---|---|
| A plan made with someone | Your coach writes your program and books each session with you. Each one lands in your calendar as an invite. |
| A reminder from a person | Reminders come the day before and again shortly before, at the lead time you choose. At the time itself, a person is on the call waiting for you. |
| A reason not to move it | Skipping means telling your coach. Moving a session is fine with 12 hours' notice: decline the invite and your coach is told. |
| A planned comeback | Your coach knows the same day you missed, because they were waiting, and books the way back with you. Away for a week? Mark the dates in the app. |
Say it's Tuesday at 5:45 pm and the tired negotiator from earlier is warming up. There's nobody to negotiate with: your coach is on the call at six with tonight's workout planned. You tap "Ready to work out", which tells your coach you're there, prop the phone on a shelf and start. On the second set of squats your knees drift in, and your coach says "knees out" while you're still in the rep. Your coach also sees your heart rate live from your Apple Watch or a Bluetooth strap. It's slow to come down after that set, so they give you a longer rest. Nothing to look up, nothing to decide.
That only works if your coach knows you. Each coach has 12 members at most, and the cap is enforced when we assign coaches. A coach who is live on every session can't stretch to hundreds, so yours remembers what you did last Tuesday. You don't pick from a list: a head coach meets you on a 30-minute call and matches you.
Sessions run 45 to 90 minutes, and most people settle at around an hour. One flat price covers as many as you book. When you pay by the session, every extra appointment is a money decision, one more thing to argue yourself out of. Here, a third session in a week costs nothing extra, so your coach plans the week you need, not the one you can afford.
It's 14 days free, then $299 a month, and the 14 days start at your first session, not at signup. A reminder comes three days before the first charge, and cancelling before then costs nothing. Counting 4.3 weeks a month, that's about $35 a session if you train twice a week, $23 at three times and $17 at four. It isn't cheap, and it isn't for everyone. Skip it if:
- the week above is already holding. Keep going; it costs nothing.
- you like to train whenever the day allows. Our sessions are appointments, which is the point; app coaching such as trainwell lets you train at any hour.
- $299 a month would strain your budget.
- you want someone in the room to spot a heavy barbell, or you want meal plans. We do neither.
If you do try it, treat the two weeks as a test of everything above. Did you turn up for every session, including the one you'd have slid to tomorrow on your own?
If you run a gym or train clients
Everything above works on clients too: the week planned with them rather than for them, the easy first session back. Three findings are specific to running appointments.
A call from a person beats an automated one. Patients at one medical practice got no reminder, an automated phone message, or a call from someone on the front desk, three days ahead.6
Parikh and colleagues, 2010, 9,835 outpatients
Oddly, patients afterwards couldn't reliably say which kind of call they'd had, so whatever the person added, it worked without being remembered. A doctor's appointment is a one-off with a fixed date, so it's a strong hint for training clients, not proof.
- Say what a missed slot costs, specifically. In two trials at one London hospital trust, a text that named what a missed appointment cost the health service cut missed appointments from 11.1% to 8.4%. Saying the same thing in general terms worked less well.8
- Let the client write the time down. At two family doctors' practices in England, missed follow-ups at the nurse clinics fell 18% against the previous six months once patients wrote the date and time on the appointment card themselves. That was a before-and-after comparison, not a randomized trial, and a consultancy run by the lead author helped fund it, but it costs nothing to try.9
Here's a reminder you can paste, sent by you the day before rather than by your booking app:
Hi Jo, I've kept 6 pm tomorrow for you. If it no longer works, tell me by noon so I can offer the hour to someone else. See you then.
It comes from a person, and it says exactly what a no-show would cost.
Sources
-
Carrera, M., Royer, H., Stehr, M., Sydnor, J. & Taubinsky, D., 2018. The limits of simple implementation intentions: evidence from a field experiment on making plans to exercise. Journal of Health Economics. ↩
-
Prestwich, A., Conner, M.T., Lawton, R.J., Ward, J.K., Ayres, K. & McEachan, R.R., 2012. Randomized controlled trial of collaborative implementation intentions targeting working adults' physical activity. Health Psychology. ↩
-
Milne, S., Orbell, S. & Sheeran, P., 2002. Combining motivational and volitional interventions to promote exercise participation: protection motivation theory and implementation intentions. British Journal of Health Psychology. 248 participants over two weeks; the 91% group also got a motivational exercise before making their plan. The abstract gives the design and the effect; the 91% and 35 to 38% figures are as reported in James Clear's summary. ↩
-
Bélanger-Gravel, A., Godin, G. & Amireault, S., 2013. A meta-analytic review of the effect of implementation intentions on physical activity. Health Psychology Review. Pools 26 studies; the effect was small to medium, and larger when people also planned for obstacles. ↩
-
Milkman, K.L. and colleagues, 2021. Megastudies improve the impact of applied behavioural science. Nature. 61,293 members of 24 Hour Fitness; the comparison group got enrolment points only, and the other 53 programs all included the basic package. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Parikh, A., Gupta, K., Wilson, A.C., Fields, K., Cosgrove, N.M. & Kostis, J.B., 2010. The effectiveness of outpatient appointment reminder systems in reducing no-show rates. The American Journal of Medicine. ↩ ↩2
-
Royer, H., Stehr, M. & Sydnor, J., 2015. Incentives, commitments, and habit formation in exercise: evidence from a field experiment with workers at a Fortune-500 company. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics. Sign-up share from the NBER working paper. ↩
-
Hallsworth, M. and colleagues, 2015. Stating appointment costs in SMS reminders reduces missed hospital appointments: findings from two randomised controlled trials. PLoS One. ↩
-
Martin, S.J., Bassi, S. & Dunbar-Rees, R., 2012. Commitments, norms and custard creams: a social influence approach to reducing did not attends (DNAs). Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. ↩
More on


